The Great Web Advertising Debate
What happened to the World Wide Web?
The answer is at the end of the article........
One of the most common debates around is over web advertising.
Some sites that you visit have so many animated banners that it
looks like a shooting gallery! Others will throw up 20 windows
of ads when you try to exit the site. I call these tactics
"scumvertising". I know of a number of people who have stopped
using the World Wide Web due to scumvertising. Some say, "The
Internet should be free of advertising!"....
.... pardon? Why?
The very nature of life on this planet is dependant on
advertising. A pretty big statement for me to make, so here's a
simplified justification:
In the animal world, the strongest survive. The most aggressive,
the most brash of the species will have the tendency to be most
successful in reproduction.
In the plant world, some plants use elaborate ornamentation to
assist in their reproduction. Some flower perfumes are so
strong, they can be detected from miles away which attracts the
necessary insects to assist in pollination.
In the world of business, those organisations who attract the
most paying customers grow. The ones that hide their candle
under a bushel, no matter how good the product or service is,
will die. Successful businesses advertise. They use the World
Wide Web to do so. They pay others to display their ads which
creates income for thousands of web masters. The ads also
generate competition amongst businesses. The victor in the
competition gains sales. The sales generate employment. The
competition leads to lower pricing and refinement of product.
OK, so the comparison is taking it to the extreme; but we seem
to be living in a society of rampant consumerism, where we want
everything for nothing if possible, and we want it now. If it
wasn't for advertising, such as seen on the World Wide Web:
- my computer would have cost more and I probably wouldn't have
it - the commercial software on my computer - as above - my
internet connection - as above - freeware would not exist in the
levels available today - I may not be able to afford to offer as
much information as I do to others - for free
Without advertising on our sites, the World Wide Web would be
elitist - available to only the rich, the government and
academia. The Internet and the World Wide Web, while having it's
pitfalls as any human system does, is probably the best thing to
happen to our species in a very long time. And it has been on
the back of advertising that the WWW has grown at the phenomal
rate it has.
In stark contrast, my dreams of the perfect world dictate there
would be no need for advertising as money would not exist - but
in my perfect world there would also be no need for computers. I
love the Internet, and computering in general, but I would trade
it in any day for a world without crime, pollution and crowding.
The Internet has provided me with a living, computers helped me
to emerge from the gutter and to learn to exist in our society.
I now not just survive, I thrive. It has allowed me to
communicate my message to an audience of thousands, and to learn
many valuable lessons in life from others.
The World Wide Web is slowed down by advertising you say? Yes,
that's correct. But not as slow as needing to leave my premises
to go to the library to carry out research. It's not anywhere as
near as slow as using the postal service to deliver documents.
Internet connections are too expensive - Yes, there is still
more room for improvement. But it's not as expensive as calling
Interstate or International via the telephone to get technical
information for products; and at least you can print out your
results straight off the screen. Connectivity equipment,
telecommunications services and Internet access has dropped
incredibly in price over the last 5 years. How have these price
drops occurred? As a direct result of advertising. Think about
it based on the model I mentioned earlier.
There's too much clutter on the 'Net and it's hard to find
anything - I agree totally. I believe we will see the 'Net
cleaning up in the years to come - not through government
intervention, but through market forces. In the meantime, think
about this - when you first drove a car, did you know how to
drive it? No, you had to learn. The Internet is the same deal,
learn how to use it properly and it will serve you well. Like in
driving, the Internet is full of obstacles. As we learn to
drive, we acquire the knowledge of avoiding those obstacles to
assist us in arriving at our destination safely.
Our inboxes are full of spam - Go check your letter box, or turn
on the T.V. Much the same there. We have free-to-air T.V.
because of advertising. Public T.V. is usually paid for from the
pockets of taxpayers. Spam mail can be minimised, learn to drive
"the car" and you'll find out how. There are some articles on
our site regarding spam reporting.
While I condone web advertising, I do believe we need to become
more responsible in how we advertise. Scumvertising is out -
responsible representation is in. Consumers are not stupid, and
while they may be bitten once or twice, they learn.. and they
remember!
I have heard many misquote about the original intentions of the
Internet. The fact is that it was a cold war initiative - a
computer network designed to survive a nuclear attack. The World
Wide Web which sits on top of the Internet was not designed to
be a free show. In the words of Tim Berners-Lee, the inventor of
the World Wide Web, from his book entitled "Weaving the Web":
"Buying books from Amazon.com and stocks from E-trade is not all
there is to the Web. Neither is the Web some idealised space
where we must remove our shoes, eat only fallen fruit, and
eschew commercialism."
The intention of the Web was never (as some have romanticised
and I originally thought myself) to be a free ride. The fact
that I can obtain the information I need and communicate with
others 24/7, partially subsidised by me viewing annoying ads, is
a small price to pay for the world it has opened up.
And remember, governments don't run countries - big business
does.
So, in answer to "What happened to the World Wide Web?"....
We happened... - We are all consumers of the products of this
money driven world..... - It is up to us to change the face of
the Internet.............. - But first we'll need to change the
world.
Related Articles: ----------------- Exit Popup Anxiety Disorder:
http://www.tamingthebeast.net/articles/exitpopug.htm
---------------------------- The gentle art of making enemies:
http://www.tamingthebeast.net/articles/gentleart.htm
---------------------------- Back Button Blues
http://www.tamingthebeast.net/articles/backbutton.htm
---------------------------- Internet 2001 - A project for your
review
http://www.tamingthebeast.net/articles/sleeknet.htm
----------------------------
Michael Bloch michael@tamingthebeast.net
http://www.tamingthebeast.net Tutorials, web content and tools,
software and community. Web Marketing, eCommerce & Development
solutions. _____________________________________________
Copyright information....If you wish to reproduce this article,
please acknowledge "Taming the Beast" by including a hyperlink
or reference to the website (www.tamingthebeast.net) & send me
an email letting me know. The article must be reproduced in it's
entirety & this copyright statement must be included. Thanks.
Visit www.tamingthebeast.net to view other great articles FREE
for reproduction!