Rules of noble succession
Rules of noble succession by Jan-Olov von Wowern
Let me first say that the rules of noble succession, as they
apply to a specific noble family, can normally not be changed.
They are determined either by:
1) the rules of succession laid down in the letter patent which
was given to the family member who was first ennobled (for
patent nobility)
or
2) the rules of succession in use at the time and the place
where the family was first recognised as noble (for original
nobility)
It follows that in the case of patent nobility the rules of
succession could only be changed by the conferring authority,
the reigning Monarch or his or hers successors (if the
constitution would allow for such changes).
In the case of the original nobility in my opinion the rules of
succession cannot ever be changed, not even by a successor of
the reigning Monarch who once recognised the family as noble,
because the rules of succession were in most cases not at the
Monarch's disposition to change. Hence, for all practical
purposes and certainly for the study of genealogy, we may assume
that noble families are bound by certain rules of succession
that must be adhered to.
When we discuss succession, we should define whether we mean the
succession to the nobility (that is, which family members in the
next generation will inherit the name, the arms and the quality
of continuing the family line), and the succession to the
headship of a noble family. As implied by the title, in this
article I will mainly discuss the succession of nobility in the
general and collective sense.
Noble succession is either agnatic or cognatic. In my genealogy
book "Find Your Noble Ancestors!", I have defined those terms as
follows: "Agnatic succession: succession to the nobility ...
continues only on the spear (male) side, from father to son."
"Cognatic succession: in many countries this was the original
form of succession among the ancient nobility, meaning the
nobility ... continued on both the spear (male) and distaff
(female) side in parallel lines".
The vast majority of all noble families have agnatic succession,
meaning both sons and daughters of a noble father are noble, but
only the grandchildren of the sons (and not of the daughters)
are noble. Certainly in most families created noble by means of
a letter patent issued by a Monarch, this is by far the most
common rule of succession.
Cognatic succession is, for practical genealogical purposes,
only relevant in a few cases where it can be shown that this was
indeed the original form of noble succession of the family, and
there is an unbroken chain of succession from these (ancient)
times down till today.
If we were to discuss the succession to the headship of a
family, it would be necessary to distinguish between the two
variants of cognatic succession, true and false. True cognatic
succession means the firstborn child, whether a son or a
daughter, has the best claims. False cognatic succession would
mean any son would inherit before a daughter regardless if he
was younger, but in the absence of sons the oldest daughter
would have the best claims.
The kingdom of Sweden today has, according to its constitution,
true cognatic succession, that is the firstborn child of the
Monarch has the best claims to the succession to the Throne.
Some other Monarchies also have this system.
If, for genealogical purposes, you want to find out if a certain
noble family as agnatic or cognatic succession, you need to
either look at the letter patent by which the family was created
noble, or, in the case of the original nobility, establish the
terms and conditions for noble succession in use at the time and
place where the family was first recognised as noble. In most
cases, the family members living today will be able to tell you
which form of succession they have.